Hey Peter, Just wanted to encourage you mate! You are doing an important job of providing surfers and other users of our coastline with a voice regarding the issue of the pulpmill in tassies north. Thanks.
Welcome to CoastView on Sun, July 06, 2008, 07:16 EST
Monday, April 30, 2007
SURFER’S CONCERNS OVER MILL PROPOSAL “HAVE NOT BEEN ADDRESSED”
Source: Surfrider Foundation Australia
::: Email this to a mate :::
Comments: Leave your comments at the end of the article. There are currently 22 comments for this article.
photo: Rider in the Storm. Surfrider Foundation Australia Northern Tasmania President Peter Whish-Wilson speaks before a crowd reported by local media to be over 3,000 strong. Photo ©2007 Thomas Moore - http://www.DigitalTasmania.com
An edited version of a speech from Peter Whish-Wilson, President Surfrider Foundation Australia Northern Tasmania branch, which was given before a packed Albert Hall in Launceston on April 1st, 2007.
The speech has been published, with additional information on the Surfrider Foundation Australia website.
I’d like to start by sharing one of my favourite quotes with you:
WE ONLY PRESERVE WHAT WE LOVE
WE ONLY LOVE WHAT WE UNDERSTAND
WE ONLY UNDERSTAND WHAT WE STUDY
The Surfrider Foundation Tasmania is a group of local people who, over the past 2 years, have tried to understand the proposed pulp mill project, and what potential impact it may have on our lives as surfers in Tasmania.
We are a community of knock-around, “normal”, every-day people, who have given up thousands of hours of time to study this project. A group of people who have put our lives on hold, contributed our own hard earned money to help fund a comprehensive scientific study into potential impacts of the proposed pulp mill on our north coast beaches.
A pulp mill that proposes to dump billions of litres of industrial effluent into a pristine stretch of coast along Bass Strait, right at one of our premier surf spots.
All this work to raise concerns, ask questions and see specific issues addressed, a process we would have expected to be comprehensive, clear and transparent.
The Surfrider Foundation has never stated it opposes a pulp mill in Tasmania. But standing here today, in front of you, I can say many of our questions and concerns have not been addressed, nor are they likely to be. So, how are we, a community group, able to say we support this project?
It may not surprise many of you that surfers would be passionate about ocean conservation, but it may surprise you that surfers, and the Surfrider Foundation International, already have a long history of conflict with, and legal action against, pulp mills around the world.
In the USA, Canada, and in Chile pulp mills have been found to have polluted the marine environment and caused human health impacts on recreational users of the coastline. Pulp mills that have been forced to change technology and clean up their act.
This has been achieved by community groups no different to our own through the use of global scientific resources energised by a passion and love for the ocean. Through this same network our local Tasmanian branch of Surfrider Foundation Australia has been able to recruit national and international scientists, some of them the best in their field, to help us in our integrated impact submission to the RPDC.
We were looking forward to public hearings. A chance to present our case. A chance to get feedback on our concerns and endevours. Our case outlined valid concerns with the proposed project and its impact on our beaches.
Where do we go from here under this new assessment project?
We have heard a lot of new information today. But if I could leave you to ponder two points that I think are of critical importance in this debate:
The RPDC process was not just a project assessment exercise, it was also about community inclusion in the planning of the proposed project. Many of those writing submissions had valid concerns that, if addressed in a fair manner, may have led to community support for the project. Due to a perceived failure in that regard, now there is only suspicion and community anger. Without community support, especially local community support, I can’t fathom that this project will have long term viability. Cutting off the RPDC process and public hearings has sent a clear message on future community involvement.
Secondly, the marine environment, as I have found out in my journey, is an extremely complex ecosystem. It is one one piece of this jig saw puzzle. I’m no scientist but I’ve put in the hours trying to understand this project, and I fail to see how anyone, especially our local government and federal representatives, can make an informed decisions on this project unless they put in the same amount of time trying to understand. They are after all just people like our bunch of surfers.
What can you do to help address such concerns?
Don’t stop at writing letters. Read widely on all the issues and concerns surrounding the pulp mill. Go beyond gathering knowledge from your local newspapers, phone a University and harness an academic. If you take the time to understand the issues in your own words, then you are in a better position to inform and lobby our politicians to do the same!
Putting the Surfrider Foundation perspective aside, I’d just like to finish today by taking the chance to say, that I personally wear many hats in this pulp mill debate. I moved back to Tasmania to invest in a in a different and unique lifestyle with my children… like many of you here today. I teach students at university, the future leaders of tomorrow, to apply rigorous analysis to the world in which they live. And I ,of course, want to surf clean oceans and this beautiful wild coast.
I’d like to say that although I wear these many hats, I don’t wear any masks! I’m happy to speak up today of the things of which I’m proud. Don’t be intimidated by this change of process, speak up and get involved in making sure your vision of Tasmania is also seen (and heard) by those who represent you.
Thank you.
Contact: Peter Whish-Wilson 0410 754 728,
Photo ©2007 Thomas Moore - http://www.DigitalTasmania.com
Posted by The Skipper on Mon, April 30, 2007 at 07:53 AM
Comments from in Tassie
Comments from
As Nor Tas surfers, a Pulp Mill in the Tamar Valley will impact us greatly for many years to come. The abolition of due process in regards to the assessment of the Pulp Mill has infuriated many. Whether you are a surfer or not, make your presence felt at the next street rally in Launceston in a month or so. Could be your last chance to make YOUR voice heard.
Peter - I was at the Albert Hall when you delivered the above speech. You did an awesome job! Thanks for the time you have put into this cause, and as stated above by Truckster, giving not only surfers, but all users of our pristine coastline a voice.
John M
North Tas Surfrider Foundation Member
Comments from Russell Campbell
[ Comment temporarily removed to comply with Section 191 of the Electoral Act 2004 ]
All comments that could be interpreted as “campaign material” or “advertising” must come with both FULL NAME and POSTAL ADDRESS included.
Comments from The Skipper in Tasmania
Hey guys n gals. . .
As we are in an election (contested in Pembroke and Nelson on May 5th) please make sure you state your full name and address on anything that addresses these elections or the candidates involved.
Section 191 of the Electoral Act 2004 requires this.
Thanks,
Thomas Moore - co-founder, editor
77 Bayview Rd
Lauderdale, TAS 7021
Comments from
many thanks guys, the truth is we need more surfers to get involved..get active...anyone wanting to join Surfrider should log onto http://www.surfrider.org.au and sign up online...it doesnt cost much to become a member (plus organic tshirts are only 30 bucks)! Its not all serious stuff either..plenty of beers/barbies/surf etc , cheers whishy
Comments from Sandy Shore in Yallingup, WA
Good on ya Pete
You are a legend.
The surfers of Yallingup and Margaret River don’t mind a bit of cold water but not when it’s a soup of chemicals and toxic wastes. Then there’s the destruction of near coast old growth trees.
There should be better laws against Gunns in Tasmania. Hope some law makers get voted in this year that will see the Gunns people planting trees rather than chopping them down and polluting the planet just so a few people can make some photocopies.
Comments from in Karratha Western Australia
Peter
Knowing how passionate you and your fellow members are in relation to this proposed development,it is apparent that from your extensive efforts, that you will succeed in the dismantling any proposal that will upset or effect one of the most pristine coastlines in the world.
You have my full support at all times.
Regards
Paul Brady
Comments from in japan
Buy as many share in the company as possible
and close it down.
Comments from in Melbourne
Peter
Thank you for the time and effort you have gone to in representing our collective interests. Whether we are facing direct contamination of our local breaks or issues on a global scale, it affects us all.
Hang tough bother. You have a great many of us behind you.
Pete Crommelin
Melbourne
Comments from in Perth
Well done Pete and others in your group,
your work takes time, energy and passion and it is because of people like you, who care, there is still hope the world can be a better place. I thank you for your contribution to our environment and for your inspiration to act.
I still believe in the power of the people, because at the end of the day, that is all we have.
Carlie
Comments from Gregor Watson in Temporarily in Turkey
Allison Ritchie, currently standing for re-election as the MLC for Pembroke, voted in favour of the [in my view extremely flawed and dangerous] legislation to create a special fast track process to facilitate the construction of the Gunns pulp mill.
If you are in that electorate and you are concerned about good governance, proper planning or the protection of our clean waters, I strongly urge you to vote against Allison Ritchie on May 5.
Gregor Watson
(enrolled as an Overseas Elector by the Australian Electoral Commission & Tasmanian Electoral Commission, & currently temporarily resident at
75 YIL MAH. ATAKENT SiTELERi, YASEMiN APT. KAT 03 D.13 KUTAHYA TURKEY)
Comments from Brendan Turriff in Clifton
Superb Effort Wishy!
Unfortunately, my job ties me to duties down South and various events on weekends also, so I couldn’t be there for the rally! I am, however currently giving you a standing ovation!! Bravo!!
You have individually dedicated much time into this Wishy and I applaud you for that alone.... the thing is, you are also very correct in what you say! If Gunns and the Government get away with this, it will be the biggest environmental disaster the state has witnessed.... and they thought the Iron Barron choked the mouth of the Tamar!
Surfrider Foundation needs as much support as they can get, so if you are a surfer and love Tassie’s coast then jump on board - It’s the least we can do.
Onya mate
Brendan Turriff
Clifton Beach
Comments from Lee Belbin in Carlton Beach Tasmania
Thanks Peter. Your work is really appreciated.
As a scientist myself, I’d say that Tasmanians MUST follow the precautionary principle and do all in our power to stop this mill because of one thing alone - that the RPDC process was bypassed. If the mill was a wonderful thing, there was no need to bypass due process. It obviously isn’t.
Lee
Comments from Gregor Watson
An article in today’s Mercury ( http://www.news.com.au/mercury/story/0,22884,21675276-3462,00.html )outlines the Federal Government’s assessment process for the proposed Gunns’ pulp mill. Essentially the public has 4 weeks to make submissions TO GUNNS (NOT THE COMMONWEALTH). Gunns will then compile a report, supposedly taking into account the main thrust of any public submissions and forward this to the Federal Environment Minister who will take 2 months to assess it. There will be no public hearings.
We’re therefore left with the situation that in Tasmania we have to trust the recommendations of a consulting company reportedly associated with both the mill’s designers and its builders and federally we have to trust Gunns to pass on our submissions. How can we have faith in either process? Where is the accountability?
By all means, send in your submissions but send a copy to Malcolm Turnbull also, regardless of the proper process. Also write to other politicians and take to the streets if needed. Demand that your voice be heard.
Comments from in Mandurah - WA
Hey Pete, what a fantastic job you’re doing mate. Please know that you have our support now & always.
My family & I fell in love with this region when we visited last year. Say NO to Gunns Ltd, say NO to the pulp mill say YES to a clean & green Tassie. May everyone get the chance to fall in love with the Tamar Valley just as she is.
We are proud of you & all the people working so hard to fight this cause.
Nicky & Brad
Comments from charlie in east coast surfer
well i guess it will open up a new kinda tourism
we could all walk along the bay of fires and identify the dead species....why dont we get a vote on why we are governed by conscienceless masons tasmania this will be the worse thing to happen her since the death of truganinni....
dont let anyone tell you any different, guns kill
just look at whats happening with the tassie devil
Comments from houston b
go for the Pulp Mill, North sucks, stuff you greenys, Get some coin for an artifical reef or a tunel fromsouth arm to southport develop us ya XXXXX
Comments from in beround
OUR FUTURE, OUR JOBS!! farkin joke, there will be no tassie left to have a future in if these XXXX cut down all our trees. rednecks suck
Comments from barnaby egerton-warburton in Sydney Australia
It continues to amaze me that in this day and age with the massive focuss on the “Global Environement” that our politicians fail to see the relationship between good governanace and good business. How many politicians personally benefit from a large company like GUNNS ramming this project through?...Its an interesting question. There are some obvious ones that I can see and then there are the back door deals that we never see and only suspect. Feasability studies should encompass all facets of a projects impact from Financial cost/profit projections all the way to environemental and human and ecological aspects, with the latter being the larger issue of concern. Ive just read the complete process that GUNNS and the Tasmanian Govt have taken to push this project through, this process is criminal. There are ways that corporations can generate returns for shareholders while at the same time taking into account environemntal issues, community and the need for jobs.....in the case of thie issue the real hero will be the federal politician and or politiacal party that puts a stop to this project and the procees that has been used to let it get as far as it already has. Im on board and so is the Sprout Board co for all we can do to help. Business and Environment go hand in hand, its not one or the other. Barnaby 43 Whistler St Manly, Sydney
Comments from
Is everyone aware that Gunns are currently refurbishing Paul Lennon’s house at the moment? I can’t get over the fact that he continually does this backdoor #### so blatantly. Surely it can only be a matter of time before he is called to answer! Paul Lennon, you and Robin Gray are the worst things that have happened to this state, and you both bring shame on Tasmania.
Comments from in Byron Bay Australia
Hey peter and crew,
Just wanted to say how proud we are of you guys for standing up and fighting this bloody awful proposal.
The whole thing is just so unsustainable and should never have been encouraged. What the hell were they thinking or were the lights on and nobody was home.
We at the Byron Bay branch are with you in spirit .
GO HARD guys
Cheers,
Don Oz
Comments from
Many thanks Don, keep in touch on the issue matey… should be an interesting few weeks/months coming up on the issue, wish I was in Byron too ..looks like youve had plenty of swell ! cheers Whishy
Post your comments in the box below.
>> Comments are moderated - defamatory or offensive content is not acceptable. Threats of any kind are not acceptable. Put simply, play the ball, not the (wo)man. Frivolous and inane comments will not be published. CoastView reserves the right to edit or remove any comment for any reason. Your public comments will include your email details, if available. Don't enter your email details if you don't want them posted. If you have concerns or issues with specific comments please contact admin@coastview.com.au
GO >> CoastView Homepage






